Season 51 castaway Rob Antonson elected to leave the competition during the show’s Oct. 7 episode
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(749x0:751x2):format(webp)/Na-Onka-Mixon-Colton-Cumbie-Rob-Antonson-100726-ddbac66d787048538c0e0bf509c43f13.jpg)
Sometimes, the tribe doesn’t speak on Survivor.
During the CBS reality competition show, contestants are pushed to their limits as they navigate life on remote islands with scarce resources, compete in grueling challenges and attempt to form alliances in a game known for deceit.
Winning the title of “Sole Survivor” and its accompanying cash prize is no easy feat, and for some contestants, the victory isn’t worth the hardship. Over the course of the show’s 51 seasons, 16 castaways have chosen to quit on their own terms rather than play until their tribe decided to vote them out.
Some castaways have gotten overwhelmed by the environment — like Na Onka Mixon and Kelly Shinn in Survivor Nicaragua — while others left for family matters, like Jenna Morasca on Survivor: All Stars. A handful have decided to play it safe with an injury despite the medical team’s clearance, like Rob Antonson in Survivor 51.
Throughout the series’ two-decade-plus run, there’s been some ambiguity on what constitutes a “quit.” Three castaways chose to leave after their vote-off rather than stay on the “Edge of Extinction” and fight for a chance to return, per their seasons’ unique twist. Meanwhile, host Jeff Probst said season 44’s Matthew Grinstead-Mayle’s decision to leave after an injury was “not a quit,” adding that “the guy was in intense pain, and even our Dr. Will said … ‘I’m not going to pull you because it’s not life or death, but I get why you’re doing that.’ ”
While the Emmy-winning host’s reaction to quitters has varied over the years, he made one thing clear in November 2023: “From this point forward if you are a Survivor player and you quit, your torch will not be snuffed,” he told Entertainment Weekly. “To get your torched snuffed, you got to play the game.”
Here’s a look back at every Survivor contestant who has quit the game.
Osten Taylor on Survivor: Pearl Islands
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Osten-Taylor-survivor-100826-e2c91f298bf5470e92af700a58e87562.jpg)
Season 7 contestant Osten Taylor made history as the first Survivor player to remove himself from the competition. At the start of the season, Taylor sold most of his clothes for supplies, leaving him vulnerable to the cold. As the days went on, he continued to struggle with the elements, and later told reporters that he’d even acquired several staph infections, per Reality Blurred.
Eventually, he lost his desire to push through and asked his tribemates to vote him out. “I’m clearly out of my element,” he said at tribal council. “I can at least say I went and tried it … and I won’t live my life saying what if.”
As he left, Probst snuffed Taylor’s torch and laid it on the ground. “With all due respect to Osten, people work too damn hard to get in this game and fight to stay alive,” he told the rest of the tribe. “If he wants to lay his torch down, so it shall be.”
Jenna Morasca on Survivor: All-Stars
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Jenna-Morasca-survivor-100826-c606baa543f648a1bb902795a088d803.jpg)
In the third episode of Survivor season 8, Morasca, the winner of Survivor: The Amazon, announced she regretted leaving her mother, who had been sick with breast cancer for 12 years.
Probst confirmed that Morasca had not received any updates about the state of her mother’s condition while she’d been on the island, and the contestant replied, “I got a feeling that she needs me there.” Morasca’s mother died eight days after she returned home, per Entertainment Weekly.
“The night I got home, she stopped eating and drinking,” Jenna later recalled to The Early Show. “She wasn’t speaking, but I kind of like whispered that ‘I’m home.’ She kind of let out this big sigh, like a big, deep breath. She didn’t talk at all or speak or kind of wake up after that.”
Sue Hawk on Survivor: All-Stars
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Sue-Hawk-survivor-100826-b3423580bfe74c7db399b3f351dc4684.jpg)
Sue Hawk left the game on day 15 of Survivor: All Stars after contestant Richard Hatch, who was known for being naked at camp, allegedly rubbed his genitals on her while passing her during an immunity challenge.
“I was sexually violated, humiliated, dehumanized and totally spent, Jeff,” she announced. “I’m done, I’m walking away.”
Afterwards on The Early Show, Hawk said that she and Hatch “have different perspectives” on the incident but “have come to terms with it and agreed to move forward and past it.”
During the same segment, Hatch said, “We see it from two different perspectives. It’s not about her apologizing to me or, from my perspective, about my apologizing to her. I’m so sorry that she feels this way. I’m so sorry that it’s been so emotional for her. I do feel for her very, very much.”
Reflecting on the incident on The New York Times’ Popcast in September 2026, Probst said, “That is maybe the hardest moment for me to watch,” adding that now, he would have handled the situation entirely differently.
In trying to prevent Hawk from quitting, Probst said he unintentionally downplayed the situation when he referred to Hatch as “sorta being inappropriate.”
He added that no one would be allowed to be naked on modern-day Survivor. “It would never happen because we now understand a lot more … which is making someone uncomfortable is enough … just your behavior is enough,” he said.
Janu Tornell on Survivor: Palau
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/janu-Tornell-survivor-100826-e56184797e65463c85ae884b5e0c9d7d.jpg)
On season 10 of Survivor, contestant Janu Tornell said she felt ostracized and like she “didn’t belong” on her tribe. After returning from a night spent alone on Exile Island, Tornell announced that she “already received what [she] needed to receive from this whole experience,” and quit the game during tribal council.
However, Tornell didn’t go home. Given it was day 27, she instead returned as a member of the jury.
Gary Stritesky on Survivor: Fiji
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Gary-Stritesky-survivor-100826-ca2aedb6ef0f4f73a245ebb690b002a3.jpg)
Gary Stritesky chose to exit season 14 of Survivor due to health-related issues. Early on, Stritesky feared he had cracked a rib during the reward challenge and reported chest pain and dizziness. The medical team evaluated him and gave him the go-ahead to continue the game.
Then, on day 10, Stritesky began to experience vertigo due to a reaction from a bug bite. Once again, the medical team cleared him to continue. But the bus driver said he “[couldn’t] even function” due to his symptoms, and with the support of his tribe, he loaded onto the medical boat and left camp.
Kathy Sleckman on Survivor: Micronesia
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Kathy-Sleckman-survivor-100826-99570b79c11c4d8a9eb9125b4fc0c132.jpg)
During season 16, contestant Kathy Sleckman was sent to Exile Island on multiple occasions and endured long stretches of severe weather with little respite. Eventually, she’d had enough.
“I was doing it for my husband, doing it for my sister who wants to live vicariously through me,” she told Probst through tears, but leaving was “the first decision I’ve made that’s for me.”
Na Onka Mixon on Survivor: Nicaragua
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Na-Onka-Mixon-survivor-100826-57112036312d4cedb1c3fd4fb1447d39.jpg)
Mixon and her castmate Shinn made Survivor history as the “latest-in-the-season quits” when they called it due to hunger and exhaustion on day 28 of 39 of their season.
The two were still allowed to sit on the jury, a controversial decision which Mixon supported. “I played the hell out of that game and made it past the merge,” she told E! Online in December 2010. “The game we played was a hard game—it was just under harsh conditions.”
Mixon added that looking back, she has no regrets. “Survivor has really changed my life in a positive aspect. I am so grateful and so blessed to have been cast by Lynne [Spillman] and to have talked to Jeff Probst and met Mark Burnett,” she said. “At a brief moment in the game when I quit I felt like I would be letting them down, but I feel like I gave them gold.”
Kelly Shinn on Survivor: Nicaragua
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Kelly-Shinn-survivor-100826-c46951e81b3147138036ab9129e07fc2.jpg)
Shinn, better known as “Purple Kelly” on her season, ended her competition alongside Mixon when Probst asked whether anyone else wanted to leave. When the two returned as jury members, Probst left their torches at tribal council as a reminder “of the decision you made to quit.”
Although Shinn was treated for parasites and low blood pressure when she left, she reflected on the experience positively when talking to E! Online. “I’m taking away one of the greatest experiences—and I mean greatest because it was so large, not necessarily because it was always the best. Just finding out what kind of person I am, what I can go through.”
Dana Lambert on Survivor: Phillipines
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Dana-Lambert-survivor-100826-f8250ee3350e4f4480fea948af436025.jpg)
On day 12 of season 25, Dana Lambert began feeling sick with nausea and a fever. Despite being cleared by the medical team and her tribemates’ best healing efforts, she felt she was too ill to continue with the game, telling Probst her pain was “like a knife.”
After the fact, Lambert told The Hollywood Reporter that she did not regret her exit. “Knowing the kind of person I am, it takes something pretty freaking severe for me to give up on something,” she said. “Truly at that point, there was no way I could have helped the tribe … and no way I was going to get better.”
Colton Cumbie on Survivor: Blood vs. Water
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Colton-Cumbie-survivor-100826-928c30e04574443a8d6c23a1b9f12b2f.jpg)
Season 27 marked Colton Cumbie’s second season on Survivor — and his second time leaving the game without being voted out. In season 24, he was medically evacuated due to suspected appendicitis, though he later revealed it was actually a bacteria infection, per E! Online.
The controversial Survivor figure broke down on day seven of his return season, saying “I don’t want to be here anymore, at all,” he said. “I don’t care about this tribe.” Probst called his exit a “very selfish move.”
“Colton, you came back for a second time because you said you wanted to show how much you’ve grown, but your behavior now shows you haven’t, and the irony is the opportunity for the growth you seek is right in front of you,” he said.
In response to backlash from Survivor fans saying he took the opportunity from someone else, he told PEOPLE in October 2013, “I’m sorry that they didn’t cast you on Survivor, but that’s not my fault. Maybe you should become more interesting.”
Lindsey Ogle on Survivor: Cagayan
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Lindsey-Ogle-survivor-100826-5d54f01eede249fea1cdcbc39f7cd8bf.jpg)
Lindsey Ogle quit season 28 in response to a conflict with her tribemate, Trish Hegarty. Their argument erupted after Lindsey was blindsided by a vote at tribal council, and Lindsey ultimately left the competition to avoid escalating the situation.
Upon reflection, Lindsey had no regrets. “I wanted to show my daughter that it’s not okay to kick someone’s ass if they get on your nerves; that you have to take a breath and walk away,” she told PEOPLE in March 2014. “So I’m proud of the decision I made.”
Julie McGee on Survivor: San Juan Del Sur
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Julie-McGee-survivor-100826-89b9846c682f40b2835fbe7a54ef1cec.jpg)
Following suit of the show’s first Blood vs. Water season, season 29 also had a mid-season quit. Julie McGee left the game after struggling with the elements, feeling ostracized by her tribe and missing her boyfriend John Rocker, who had been voted out earlier in the game. In their last conversation at camp, Probst pushed McGee to consider the ramifications of her exit for her tribe.
“I feel for the people that I left behind that I felt I could have helped, or they could have helped me. But I don’t regret it,” she told TVGuide.com in November 2014. “I really proved to myself what I could do out there.”
Bi Nguyen on Survivor: David vs. Goliath
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Bi-Nguyen-survivor-100826-41bce6b7a9c147b79f1d83a6f24287c0.jpg)
MMA fighter Bi Nguyen was recovering from a medial collateral ligament (MCL) injury when she entered season 37, but further sprained it during an immunity challenge on day 9. The medical team wrapped up her leg and confirmed she was safe to stay in the game; however, due to her profession, Nguyen made the decision to remove herself as a means to avoid further injury.
“I was so scared for my career. And I didn’t want to leave the game because I felt I was doing good in the game,” she told Entertainment Weekly afterwards. “It was just a tough decision and it took hours and hours of a lot of crying and a lot of thinking, and I decided that my knee wouldn’t last the island and it wouldn’t last the competitions.”
Hannah Rose on Survivor 45
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Hannah-Rose-survivor-100826-da5d31581d324ab2bc1c0173b803f803.jpg)
During the premiere of season 45, Hannah Rose told her tribemates she missed the comforts of home, later telling Entertainment Weekly her departure was due to a combination of “caffeine, nicotine, sleep and food withdrawal.”
“I see five people who want to be here more than anything,” Rose told her fellow castaways at tribal council. “But everything in my body is like, ‘I am not going back to that camp.’ ” So, rather than writing down names that night, Probst conducted a verbal vote-out.
“Sorry to the haters that think that I threw away an opportunity,” she told Entertainment Weekly in September 2023. “But I’m so glad that those tribemates got to keep playing and give you the show that you want to see.”
Sean Edwards on Survivor: 45
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(842x372:844x374):format(webp)/Sean-Edwards-Survivor-45-100926-a3b67117730b4ac4af6db4083013844d.jpg)
During episode 4 of season 45, Sean Edwards followed in the footsteps of his castmate Rose and asked his tribe to vote him out.
“Being here, I’ve realized that my true adventure of a lifetime is back home with my husband, Matt,” Edwards announced at tribal council. “I know how bad that all four of you really want this — I don’t want to take your dream away from you, because it’s not mine.”
Reflecting on the decision months later, Edwards questioned his choice. “I’ll be honest with myself and with everyone else, there definitely is an intense feeling of regret about my decision,” he told Entertainment Weekly in October 2023.
Rob Antonson on Survivor 51
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(799x0:801x2):format(webp)/Rob-Antonson-survivor-100726-2-cadc95f2bacb4a4eae15cc1895c3d751.jpg)
Antonson became the latest quit his season 51 exit. During episode 2, the Rhode Islander tried to vote himself out as a self-proclaimed attempt to save a tribemate, but his efforts were thwarted when production informed him that castaways cannot write their own name at tribal council.
One episode later, he asked the medical team to examine a cut on his foot. “I feel like just quitting is just ruining the game,” he said in a confessional. “If you’re going out for medical reasons, that’s totally different.”
The medical team cleared him to stay in the game, but Antonson chose to leave out of a precaution for his health. However, Antonson doesn’t believe he quit the game.
“I don’t feel like I quit Survivor. I feel like quitting is something you just give up on, okay?” he told Entertainment Weekly in October 2026. “But there are certain circumstances that go to taking yourself out of the game, and that’s what I did.”