‘Riveting’ BBC Crime Drama Wins Praise for Its Fresh Twist on an Agatha Christie Classic

Fans of gripping murder mysteries have another reason to visit BBC iPlayer, with a critically praised adaptation of Agatha Christie’s The ABC Murders bringing a fresh and unsettling take on one of the author’s best-loved stories.

Starring John Malkovich as the legendary detective Hercule Poirot and Rupert Grint as Inspector Crome, the three-part crime drama follows a chilling series of murders that appear to follow an alphabetical pattern. With stylish direction, atmospheric settings and a talented supporting cast, the series has earned enthusiastic praise from viewers who describe it as both “riveting and fresh.”

BBC One - The ABC Murders, Series 1, Episode 2

John Malkovich Takes on the Iconic Role of Hercule Poirot

Directed by Alex Gabassi and written by Sarah Phelps, an experienced adapter of Agatha Christie’s novels, The ABC Murders transports viewers to Britain in 1933.

This time, Poirot is an ageing detective whose career and reputation appear to be fading. His life takes a disturbing turn when he begins receiving mysterious letters signed “A.B.C.” from someone who seems determined to challenge him.

The anonymous killer appears to be selecting victims according to the alphabet, murdering them in alphabetical order and leaving an ABC Railway Guide beside each body.

The ABC Murders

View 2 Images

Viewers called it ‘fresh and riveting’(Image: BBC/Mammoth Screen/Agatha Christie Ltd)

As the body count rises, Poirot finds himself caught in a sinister game with a murderer who seems to know exactly how to provoke him.

Alongside Malkovich and Grint, the cast includes Eamon Farren, Andrew Buchan and Shirley Henderson, all contributing to the drama’s atmospheric portrayal of a country gripped by fear.

Viewers Call the Adaptation ‘Riveting and Fresh’

View 2 Images

John Malkovich stars in the whodunnit(Image: BBC/Mammoth Screen/Agatha Christie Ltd)

Although reimagining such a familiar literary character is never an easy task, many viewers have praised Malkovich’s interpretation of Poirot and the series’ distinctive approach to the original story.

One IMDb reviewer admitted initially feeling uncertain about the casting but quickly changed their mind.

“In the first few minutes I was unsure about Malkovich as Poirot, but he plays the character well and with conviction,” they wrote.

Praising the production’s visual style, the viewer continued: “The direction is quite arty and that’s a real positive. 3 hours and I enjoyed every minute. Well done BBC, more please!”

Another viewer described the adaptation as “refreshingly intellectual and artistically thoughtful,” singling out Malkovich’s performance for particular praise.

They highlighted the way the drama explores emotions, egos, gender roles, politics and the tension between experience and ambition, describing these as just some of the obstacles standing between Poirot and the truth.

‘Brilliant’ Acting, Costumes and Set Design

The praise hasn’t been limited to the lead performances.

Another enthusiastic viewer highlighted practically every aspect of the production, including its set design, costumes, writing, acting and musical score.

“Brilliant set design, wardrobe, writing, acting and score. Suspenseful, engaging, thought provoking and witty,” they commented.

They also appreciated the series’ emphasis on traditional filmmaking and performances rather than relying on Hollywood-style spectacle or computer-generated effects.

For this viewer, the real pleasure of watching The ABC Murders was following the psychological details of the investigation.

Even when viewers believe they know who committed the crimes, the more compelling question remains: why did the killer do it, and who will be targeted next?

A Different Take on Agatha Christie’s Beloved Detective

Not everyone approaches a new adaptation of a classic novel with an open mind, particularly when it involves a character as iconic as Hercule Poirot.

However, another viewer welcomed the changes, explaining that it had been decades since they last read the original book, making this version feel like an entirely new mystery.

They praised Malkovich’s interpretation as a “whole new Poirot” and highlighted the supporting cast, beautiful scenery and impressive cinematography.

The reviewer also appreciated the decision to explore a different background story for Poirot, including suggestions that his professional standing is beginning to decline.

They acknowledged that some traditional Christie fans might prefer a more faithful adaptation but argued that screenwriters should have the freedom to reinterpret familiar stories and introduce new elements.

Pointing to the 1972 film Murder on the Orient Express, they noted that even celebrated adaptations have taken liberties with Christie’s original material.

Ultimately, The ABC Murders offers a darker, more psychologically focused interpretation of one of the author’s most recognisable mysteries.

With John Malkovich leading a strong cast and an alphabetical killing spree at the heart of the story, the three-part drama has given viewers plenty to appreciate.

All three episodes of The ABC Murders are currently available to stream on BBC iPlayer.