British Music Tutor, 32, Was ‘Executed’ in Florida After Travelling to Meet Man She Met on Fetish Website, Court Hears
A 32-year-old British music tutor was allegedly lured thousands of miles from home and brutally murdered by a man who prosecutors say exploited her mental health struggles for his own sadistic gratification.
Sonia Exelby, from Southsea, Portsmouth, was found stabbed to death in a shallow grave in Florida on October 17, 2025. Her alleged killer, Dwain Chadwick Hall, 54, is now standing trial in Ocala, where prosecutors have described him as a predator who manipulated the vulnerable woman before carrying out what they called an execution.
Hall, who allegedly used the online name “Alpha Sadist”, is accused of kidnapping and murdering Sonia after she travelled to the United States last October. He has pleaded not guilty.
Opening the prosecution’s case on Tuesday, assistant state attorney Amy Berndt told jurors that Sonia had been targeted by a man who was sexually aroused by violence against women.
“She was brutally murdered by a predator,” Berndt said, describing Hall as someone who took pleasure in the rape and torture of women.
She portrayed Sonia as a kind and gentle person who had struggled with mental illness for much of her life, arguing that Hall deliberately exploited her vulnerability.
How an online relationship allegedly turned deadly

Prosecutors told the court that Sonia first encountered Hall on a fetish website approximately two years before her death.
According to investigators, she had been communicating with numerous men through the platform, which has since been shut down, while searching for someone willing to kill her.
Sonia had reportedly experienced serious mental health difficulties throughout her life, including self-harm and previous suicide attempts.
Prosecutors said her condition had deteriorated, leaving her increasingly desperate to end her life. However, rather than receiving the help she needed, she allegedly became the target of men who were willing to discuss increasingly disturbing ways of killing her.
Berndt told the jury that Sonia had been receiving messages from men describing how they would murder her in torturous and degrading ways.
She said several men appeared interested in carrying out the request, but Hall gradually gained Sonia’s trust and allegedly manipulated her until he secured the role of the person she would meet.
“One man would manipulate and groom Sonia until he won the job of being her executioner,” Berndt told the court.
“That person was the defendant Dwain Hall.”
The prosecutor argued that Hall recognised Sonia’s mental health struggles and used them to his advantage, ultimately arranging to meet her when she was thousands of miles away from her family and familiar surroundings.
Hall allegedly demanded £3,000 to kill her

The court heard that Sonia and Hall eventually moved their conversations from the fetish website to an encrypted messaging application that automatically deleted messages.
Prosecutors also alleged that Hall’s online profile, under the name “Alpha Sadist”, contained a disturbing description of the type of relationship he wanted.
His biography reportedly stated that he would “love to find a domestic pain sl*t for complete control”.
According to the prosecution, the pair had initially attempted to arrange a meeting in March 2025, with Hall allegedly agreeing to kill Sonia. However, that plan fell through.
Prosecutors claimed the failed arrangement prompted Hall to consider making money from the situation.
Berndt told jurors that Hall subsequently demanded Sonia bring $4,000 with her when she travelled to Florida, equivalent to approximately £3,000.
The pair allegedly settled on October 2025 for their next meeting.
Sonia booked a flight to Gainesville, Florida, and arranged accommodation in a rental property near Ocala.
Before the meeting, Hall had allegedly purchased a shovel and a rope. Prosecutors also told the court that he worshipped Anubis, the ancient Egyptian god associated with death.
Sonia changed her mind after arriving in Florida, prosecutors say

Although Sonia had reportedly travelled to the United States intending to die, prosecutors believe she changed her mind after arriving.
However, the prosecution alleges that Hall proceeded with the killing regardless.
Berndt told the jury that Hall eventually got Sonia alone, far from her home and support network, before stabbing her to death and burying her body.
The court heard that Sonia’s semi-naked body was discovered in woodland on October 17, 2025. She had suffered four stab wounds.
Investigators subsequently began examining Hall’s movements in the days leading up to the discovery.
According to prosecutors, his mobile phone records placed him at the exact location where Sonia’s body was later found for approximately one hour and 20 minutes, just five days before her remains were discovered.
The evidence also included items recovered during searches of Hall’s property.
Police reportedly discovered a shovel stained with Sonia’s blood inside his home. Investigators also recovered a knife from a package Hall had sent to a friend in Ohio.
Phone evidence allegedly revealed attempts to erase Sonia

Another significant part of the prosecution’s case centres on Hall’s mobile phone.
When questioned by police, Hall allegedly spent four hours giving investigators a false account of events, which prosecutors described as a bizarre and nonsensical story.
However, the court heard that he eventually changed his account and admitted communicating with Sonia for years.
Prosecutors further alleged that Hall had attempted to erase every trace of the British woman’s presence from his phone.
A forensic examination of the device reportedly uncovered nude photographs of Sonia, along with numerous images depicting women being raped, tortured and murdered.
The prosecution also alleged that Hall had sexual contact with Sonia and subjected her to physical violence, including hitting and choking her.
Berndt argued that the evidence pointed to a killing motivated not simply by Sonia’s stated desire to die, but by Hall’s own gratification.
She told the jury that the evidence would demonstrate that he beat, stabbed and murdered Sonia for his own sadistic pleasure.
Defence insists Hall did not murder Sonia

Despite the allegations presented by prosecutors, Hall’s defence team has rejected the accusation that he killed Sonia.
Addressing the jury, his lawyer urged them to consider all the evidence before reaching a conclusion, arguing that the facts would ultimately show that Hall was not responsible for her murder.
“We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case, you will arrive at the decision that Dwain Hall did not murder,” the defence lawyer told the court.
Hall has pleaded not guilty to the charges.
The trial is continuing in Ocala, Florida, as jurors hear the competing accounts of what happened to Sonia after she travelled from Britain to meet the man she had known online.
Support for anyone affected by suicide or mental health difficulties:
If you or someone you know is struggling, confidential support is available through the following organisations:
-
CALM: www.thecalmzone.net | 0800 585 858
-
Heads Together: www.headstogether.org.uk
-
HUMEN: www.wearehumen.org
-
Mind: www.mind.org.uk | 0300 123 3393
-
Samaritans: www.samaritans.org | 116 123
In the UK, anyone who needs someone to talk to can contact Samaritans free of charge on 116 123, at any time.