‘Survivor 51’ Star Brady Booker Reveals What Happened to the Piece of His Thumb He Cut Off During Filming
Brady Booker’s injury on Survivor 51 was painful enough to watch, but what happened to the piece of his severed thumb afterward has become an unexpected part of his story on the show.

The 27-year-old professional wrestler accidentally sliced off a portion of his thumb while chopping wood at the Toka tribe’s camp during Episode 2. The injury left him bleeding heavily and fearing that he could be forced to leave the competition. Now, Booker has revealed how the show’s crew preserved the severed piece and offered an update on his recovery.
Speaking on The TMZ Podcast, Booker said his thumb was doing “good,” although he hinted that viewers would learn more about the injury in upcoming episodes.
A Wood-Chopping Accident That Nearly Ended His Game

The incident occurred while Booker was cutting wood with a machete. He accidentally struck his thumb, removing a small but significant piece from the upper corner.
The wound bled heavily, and the sight of the severed piece stuck to the machete made the moment even more unsettling. The show’s medical team was called in to assess the injury and provide treatment.
Despite the severity of the cut, Booker was eventually cleared to continue competing. His thumb was bandaged, and he was given antibiotics.
However, his immediate concern was not just the pain. He was also worried that the injury might bring his Survivor journey to an abrupt end.
Booker explained that once he realized he could still move his thumb, his attention turned to controlling the bleeding and convincing the production team that he was fit to remain in the game.
“I was like, ‘OK, how do I stop this bleeding and how do I get the producer to look at me like he wants me to stay,’” he recalled on The TMZ Podcast.
The possibility of being medically evacuated left him with what he described as “dark and scary” thoughts. He even joked that he went through “the five stages of grief” as he contemplated losing his chance to compete.
Ultimately, he was grateful that the medical team allowed him to stay.
The Crew Turned His Injury Into an Unusual Souvenir
![]()
After the episode aired on September 30, Booker shared a surprising memento on Instagram: a necklace containing the piece of his thumb, preserved in resin.
The necklace was made by Survivor’s art department and designed to resemble an immunity idol. The preserved piece of skin and nail sits inside a charm surrounded by beads.
The unusual keepsake came about after Booker asked the production and medical teams to save the severed piece for him.
In his Episode 2 “Field Notes,” host Jeff Probst described how Booker remained remarkably focused on the missing piece even while dealing with the injury.
“The crazy part is that even though Brady was in obvious pain, with blood pouring out, he was still aware enough to ask his tribemates to try and find the tip of the thumb in the dirt!” Probst wrote.
According to Probst, Booker’s tribemates located the piece and placed it in a shell to keep it safe until the medical team arrived.
![]()
Once his injury had been treated, Booker humorously pleaded with the medical staff to wrap the piece and place it in a cooler so he could take it home after filming.
“Talk about a one of a kind Survivor souvenir,” Probst remarked. “Most players are happy with a treemail.”
Brady Booker Pushes Through the Pain
Although Booker was allowed to continue, the injury did not immediately stop hurting. During the first challenge after the accident, he experienced persistent, throbbing pain in his thumb.
Still, he chose to push through the discomfort and test his limits.
Looking back on the incident, the former football player has found humor in the experience. “If you’re gonna be dumb, you gotta be tough,” he said.
Booker also explained that he has undergone seven surgeries in the past, making him familiar with injuries and the process of managing pain. He acknowledged having a “sick” fascination with finding out how much physical discomfort his body can withstand.
His determination to continue competing also earned praise from Probst, who highlighted the commitment Booker showed despite the obvious pain and heavy bleeding.
More Details to Come on ‘Survivor 51’
Booker’s recovery and the aftermath of the accident remain part of his ongoing Survivor 51 story. While he has confirmed that his thumb is doing well, he has teased that viewers can expect further updates in upcoming episodes.
The incident has already become one of the season’s most memorable moments, not only because of the graphic injury but also because of Booker’s determination to remain in the competition—and the extraordinary souvenir he ultimately took away from the experience.
Survivor 51 airs Wednesdays at 8/7c on CBS.