A routine episode of The Chase suddenly turned controversial after Amanda pleaded with teammate Robbie to play it safe rather than gamble for more money. Although the decision helped him reach the Final Chase, viewers accused the contestants of draining the excitement from the game, with some claiming the ITV favourite has “gone down the toilet.” What was meant to be smart strategy has now sparked a fierce debate among fans. But was the criticism really justified?

THE Chase fans fumed the ITV show had ‘gone down the toilet’ after a contestant’s surprising decision.

Presenter Bradley Walsh welcomed four new players hoping to win big.

The host and four contestants, Amanda, Robbie, Alex, and Sheila, on the game show "The Chase."

The Chase fans were left fuming over a contestant’s decision Credit: ITV

A contestant on "The Chase" game show stands opposite the host.

Robbie got £4,000 in his cash builder round Credit: ITV

A female quiz contestant from "The Chase" speaks to the camera.

Viewers were unimpressed with Amanda’s advice to teammate Robbie Credit: ITV

Chaser Shaun Wallace was on top form – as the barrister caught the first two contestants with ease.

HR Manager Robbie, from Hampshire, was the third player up for the head-to-head rounds.

He managed to earn a respectable £4,000 in the opening cash builder.

Robbie then turned to sole remaining teammate Amanda to advise which offer to take

Read more on The Chase

Things took an unexpected turn when she told him: “Robbie, you are capable of the top, but please go low.”

Amanda added: “I need you back here, so any money is better than no money. So please, I’m begging.”

Although Robbie chose to play for the £4,000 from the cash builder, viewers were far from impressed with Amanda’s advice.

One fumed online: “This is an absolute joke now!

“Why does the low offer even exist in the first place? The Chase has gone down the toilet.”

Another added: “Chick chick chick chicken. Hope to god you flipping lose.”

While a third simply shared: “Nooooooo!”

Robbie narrowly got through the head-to-head, bringing his £4,000 to the Final Chase.

In Amanda’s own turn, she managed to get £6,000 in the cash builder.

Having also advanced, she and Robbie were then playing for £10,000 against Shaun.

They got a score of 11 – but the chaser ended their game with 35 seconds remaining.

The Chase first premiered on ITV back in 2009 and has become a firm favourite among viewers since then. The roster of professional quizzers (‘chasers’) has grown significantly since the show’s launch.

  • Mark Labbett (2009 – present): Known as ‘The Beast’, Mark is a former Maths teacher and previously won £32,000 on Who Wants to be a Millionaire? Mark has also reprised his role as a Chaser in the US and Australian versions of the show.
  • Shaun Wallace (2009 – present): Shaun, a barrister and former Mastermind champion, goes by the ‘Dark Destroyer’. Shaun has appeared on the Australian version of The Chase. In 2008, he finished as runner-up to Barry Simmons in Are You an Egghead?, a contest to find a new member of the then-BBC quiz team.
  • Anne Hegerty (2010 – present): A former contestant on Mastermind, Fifteen To One and Are You an Egghead?, Anne goes by ‘The Governess’. Since joining The Chase, she appeared on I’m A Celebrity… in 2018.
  • Paul Sinha (2011-present): Comedian and qualified doctor Paul joined the Chaser line-up in 2011, taking the nickname ‘The Sinnerman’. He has appeared on The Weakest Link, University Challenge and Brain of Britain. In 2018, Paul starred in series 8 of popular game show Taskmaster.
  • Jenny Ryan (2015 – present): Known as ‘The Vixen’, Jenny was previously in a winning team on Only Connect. She also appeared in Mastermind, The Weakest Link and Fifteen To One before joining The Chase in 2015.
  • Darragh Ennis (2020 – present): A postdoctoral researcher, Darragh joined The Chase in 2020 as ‘The Menace’. He is the first former contestant to join the line-up, having been part of a winning team against Paul Sinha in 2017.

However, other players have enjoyed much different outcomes on The Chase.

Steven Sneade from Liverpool recently opened up about winning £5,700 – and his time filming.

Meanwhile, headteacher Tim McCarthy passed away just one month after winning half of a £100,000 jackpot on the show.

The Chase airs on ITV1 and ITVX.

A man from behind, looking left, with a timer of 0:35 and a score of 11.

Shaun caught the team with 35 seconds to spare Credit: ITV